Lawsuit Docs & Updates

Below are the relevant documents in the case. The only documents left out are procedural documents (like to set up electronic filing by the parties) that have no significance to the case.

Case # W-13-CA-022
U.S. District Court, Western District, Waco Division

01/25/2013 Plaintiff [1] Original Petition–(also see Table of Contents below)
**NOT FILED For convenience only **Table of Contents for [1] Original Petition
03/22/2013 Defendant Oncor [11] Motion to Dismiss
03/22/2013 Defendants TXU & EFH [12] Joint Motion to Dismiss
03/25/2013 Defendants TXU & EFH [13] Proposed Order Granting [12]Joint Motion to Dismiss
03/25/2013 Court [14] Order for Plaintiff to Respond to Motions to Dismiss [11]&[12]
03/28/2013 Defendant Oncor [15] Rule 7.1 Disclosure Statement
04/01/2013 Defendants TXU & EFH [16] Rule 7.1 Disclosure Statement
04/05/2013 Plaintiff [17] Response to Oncor’s [11]Motion to Dismiss
04/05/2013 Plaintiff [18] Response to TXU & EFH’s [12]Joint Motion to Dismiss
04/11/2013 Defendant Oncor [19] Reply to [17]Plaintiff’s Response to Oncor’s [11]Motion to Dismiss

Download all documents in file (Click on “Regular Download”, then “Click here to Download”)


04/21/2013– Smart Meter Lawsuit Filed

A lawsuit was recently filed in Texas claiming that smart meters violate wiretapping laws, invade people’s privacy, and that utilities are stealing the smart meter data in violation of Texas law.

As we follow this lawsuit, we will refer to it as the “Wiretap Lawsuit”.

The lawsuit was filed in January 2013 in Waco federal court (technically, the U.S. District Court, Western District, Waco Division) against:

  • Oncor Electric Delivery Co., LLC;
  • TXU Energy Retail Co., LLC; and
  • Energy Future Holdings Corp.

There are 4 main causes of action to the lawsuit. Oncor is accused of being the primary actor in most of the wrongdoing, with TXU and EFH being mostly accused of joint liability (aiding/abetting/conspiracy/etc.).

The 4 main causes of action are:

1) Wiretapping–the smart meters are violating both Texas and federal wiretap laws; (18 USC 2511 & 18 USC 2520 (federal), Tex.Penal Code 16.02(b) & Tex. Code of Crim. Proc., Art. 18.20, Sec. 16)

2) Invasion of privacy–Intrusion on seclusion–the smart meters collect and constantly transmit such intimate details of the activities of a given home that it violates Texas laws regarding invasion of privacy; (See O’Connor’s Texas Causes of Action 2013, Invasion of Privacy–Intrusion on Seclusion. Older versions will have it, too. )

3) Conversion (theft)–Texas law states unequivocally that the data from a smart meter belongs to the customer unless they expressly consent to allow the utilities access to it. The lawsuit alleges that the defendants are taking the plaintiff’s smart meter data without the legally required consent. (See Texas Utilities Code §39.107(b) )

4) Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED)–the plaintiff’s petition alleges that because she wouldn’t allow Oncor to install a smart meter on her home, Oncor bullied, terrorized, and intimidated her for months. (See O’Connor’s Texas Causes of Action 2013, Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress. Older versions will have it, too. )

While the IIED claim only applies to this plaintiff’s particular circumstances, the other claims can be applied to almost anyone in Texas who has a smart meter. So this is a lawsuit that will affect, at least, all Texans. It could have heavy influence on smart meters throughout the country, too.

One thought on “Lawsuit Docs & Updates

  1. I am a Houston resident and have suffered greatly since the installation of my smart meter.(Aug 2011) a few months after, I began to hear these pulsing sounds constantly heard throughout my home and property day and night. (modulated pulsed microwaves) At times, usually in the morning hours the frequency would get stronger, then I would feel subtle electrical sensations and burning in various area of my body. ( It is known as an electromagnetic field, which I have felt every night to varying degrees for the past 1 1/2 yrs. Two months after hearing the pulses I became hypersensitive to many electrical sources, consequently very ill at times since the installation of my smart meter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s